What do you think about this trade offer?

[mood77]

I have been offered:

Pujols
Dempster
Ellsbury

for

Halladay
Berkman


What do you guys think about this? I still have Adrian Gonzalez that I can use as a Utility batter to replace Berkman
Thanks for any thoughts on this

[Dr. Jack]

How big is pitching in your league? If not a pitching dominating league I'd consider it. Pujols is best fantasy player in game bar none so I'd be tempted

[mood77]

It's pretty big...right now, Halladay is sitting at 184 overall points and Pujols has 124...standard default cbs league settings

Guy has been after Halladay. I countered with Halladay and Berkman for Pujols and Cain

I like Cain better than Dempster and there is no telling what Ellsbury will do this year

Thanks for the response Dr. Jack

[Sweetleaf22]

Originally Posted by mood77

I have been offered:

Pujols
Dempster
Ellsbury

for

Halladay
Berkman


What do you guys think about this? I still have Adrian Gonzalez that I can use as a Utility batter to replace Berkman
Thanks for any thoughts on this

would do the trade in a second.........your getting the best player in deal,,,,,,albert


ellsbury ave is prob over 100 points better than Berk too

[bigsportsguy2006]

i agree with jack ... yes pujols seems like the best fantasy player, but if it is a pitching-heavy stat league, then he isnt the best player. as shown above, halladay has 184 points to pujols' 124 points ...

i think it is very important to keep in mind if it is a pitcher or hitter friendly league when trying to make trades.

[upinya83]

I would do it also - As of now, Pujols is only the 4th best 1B too, which will change by the end of the season. So will his numbers in comparison to Halladay.

I think Cain or even Dempster will be closer in points to Halladay than Berkman will be to Pujols, so I think you're getting the better end of the deal.

Its also imo easier to fill a weak pitcher spot by finding good matchups and 2 start pitchers on waiver wire, than it is to fill a weak 1B spot