Who should be my keepers?

[Wr3ck3d]

In our pool we get 4 keepers, who should I keep?
Scoring stats from last year should be the same as this year:

Batters Stat Categories: Runs (R), Home Runs (HR), Runs Batted In (RBI), Stolen Bases (SB), Batting Average (AVG)
Pitchers Stat Categories: Wins (W), Saves (SV), Strikeouts (K), Earned Run Average (ERA), (Walks + Hits)/ Innings Pitched (WHIP)



Players
Alberto Callaspo 149/562 61 10 56 5 .265
Carl Crawford 184/600 110 19 90 47 .307
Johnny Damon 146/539 81 8 51 11 .271
Chipper Jones 84/317 47 10 46 5 .265
A.J. Pierzynski 128/474 43 9 56 3 .270
Ian Stewart 99/386 54 18 61 5 .256
Ichiro Suzuki 214/680 74 6 43 42 .315
Miguel Tejada 171/636 71 15 71 2 .269
Troy Tulowitzki 148/470 89 27 95 11 .315
Joey Votto 177/547 106 37 113 16 .324
Matt Wieters 111/446 37 11 55 0 .249
Ryan Zimmerman 161/525 85 25 85 4 .307

Pitchers
Clay Buchholz 173.2 17 0 120 2.33 1.20
Joba Chamberlain 71.2 3 3 77 4.40 1.30
Frank Francisco 52.2 6 2 60 3.76 1.27
Matt Garza 204.2 15 1 150 3.91 1.25
Liván Hernández 211.2 10 0 114 3.66 1.32
Edwin Jackson 209.1 10 0 181 4.47 1.39
Ian Kennedy 194.0 9 0 168 3.80 1.20
Francisco Liriano 191.2 14 0 201 3.62 1.26
Daisuke Matsuzaka 153.2 9 0 133 4.69 1.37
Ricky Nolasco 157.2 14 0 147 4.51 1.28
Roy Oswalt 211.2 13 0 193 2.76 1.03
Clayton Richard 201.2 14 0 153 3.75 1.41
Justin Verlander 224.1 18 0 219 3.37 1.16


Thanks!

[dhunter]

votto
crawford
tulo

toss up between zimmerman and verlander

gl

[bigsportsguy2006]

wow ... no ichiro or buckholtz in there dhunter? ... hmm, tough

[Quiksilver]

I'd go with Crawford, Tulo, Votto. For the 4th it would be between Verlander or Liriano

[Chris46139]

Originally Posted by Quiksilver

I'd go with Crawford, Tulo, Votto. For the 4th it would be between Verlander or Liriano

not too shabby right there

[Quiksilver]

Originally Posted by Chris46139

not too shabby right there

Definitely not a bad way to start. Especially at SS with Tulo

[Wr3ck3d]

Thanks for the replies.
Crawford, Tulo and Votto were all on my list. Just wasn't sure of my 4th. Still not too sure, haha.

[rhgraham]

nolasco to bounce back

[Ron Mexico]

Def... Crawford, Tulo, Votto and Verlander.

Nice 4 guys to start with.

[dhunter]

Originally Posted by bigsportsguy2006

wow ... no ichiro or buckholtz in there dhunter? ... hmm, tough

buckholtz maybe...def not ichiro

[Ron Mexico]

Originally Posted by dhunter

buckholtz maybe...def not ichiro

Ichiro is a 6-7 rounder. Verlander is a top 10 every year. Buckholtz could have a better year but you might be able to get him in the draft.