who would you rather have

[darealist2]

big papi & manny

or

thome,konerko,+dye?

[Dr. Jack]

That is a tough choice.

Manny is the best hitter in baseball and Ortiz is right behind him (JMO)

I like Konerko a lot, Thome is a monster and Dye when he is on puts up good numbers.

I think you have to take Ortiz and Manny

[Gobbler's Knob]

Originally Posted by Dr. Jack

That is a tough choice.

Manny is the best hitter in baseball and Ortiz is right behind him (JMO)

I like Konerko a lot, Thome is a monster and Dye when he is on puts up good numbers.

I think you have to take Ortiz and Manny

Manny just went 1 for 8 and has been killing my fantasy team all year, give me a break, I'll take those white sox guys anyday.

[rjb1816]

i don't even think this is a contest...manny and ortiz would kill the other 3 as far as pure talent...of course if you needed a spot for all 3 positions you'd take the quantity

[guzzi]

twinz had papi...lol...