Fred McGriff, hall of famer or not?

[Dr. Jack]

& why?

[Chris46139]

Not right away but he will get in. Hard to keep a guy out who has 493 HR and not linked to PE's in this era, has to figure in when it will keep a lot of guys out

[blinc]

remembering those futile years with the cubs, not a chance in hell. he was terrible by then and continued to hang on for more years after he stunk with the cubs. he couldnt bend over to catch a low throw and his defense was poor. he was a "me" guy and i hate those type of players.

[uva3021]

futile years with cubs?

i remember one of his 3 years though he hit over .300, 30hrs, 100+ RBI, OPS .900 +

he was very goot player for a long time, never considered the best 1B in teh game, i say no, but may get in on his 6th or 7th ballot

[Romanowski]

edit

[Gerk]

Fred McGriff more likely to get into the Pitchmen Hall of Fame for his historic Tom Emanski ads than the MLB Hall of Fame

[upinya83]

Originally Posted by Gerk

Fred McGriff more likely to get into the Pitchmen Hall of Fame for his historic Tom Emanski ads than the MLB Hall of Fame

yes that was good work on those commercials by crimedog