NL / AL Cy Young

[Seanie Mac]

AL

beckett - sabathia - king felix ?

NL

lincecum - carpenter - wainwright


beckett & carpenter


thoughts?

[huscroft6]

Beckett lost it in the last 3 starts.

Felix deserves it. Much better ERA than both, more K's, and a number of more quality starts. This should be his award.


And Lincecum should have another one.

[Bobtheicon]

Smoltz

[upinya83]

beckett has been horrible last 3 weeks - last 3 starts given up 12 homers i saw this morning lol

too bad the royals cant give greinke any wins

NL cy young is gonna be close between those 3 i think, could go to any of those three and you'd have a hard time arguing against it

[JSi922]

no one in the AL deserves it this year. every ace has been getting lit up lately.

i would actually lean to sabathia as he has been pitching real well now.

i was leaning toward doc, but hes getting lit up....hernandez, not there yet...verlander and beckett have been getting lit up....greinke came back down to earth hard.


maybe rivera??


NL should be lincecum or carpenter...nobody else,,but lean toward lincecum

[Bisket]

felix

linecum and carpenter will battle it out

[huscroft6]

Originally Posted by ronaldo922

no one in the AL deserves it this year. every ace has been getting lit up lately.

i would actually lean to sabathia as he has been pitching real well now.

i was leaning toward doc, but hes getting lit up....hernandez, not there yet...verlander and beckett have been getting lit up....greinke came back down to earth hard.


maybe rivera??


NL should be lincecum or carpenter...nobody else,,but lean toward lincecum

Have you looked at Hernandez's numbers??

[upinya83]

Hernandez - 2.77ERA 13-5 1CG 1SHO 179K 55BBx 1.18 Whip
Greinke ---- 2.43ERA 12-8 5CG 2SHO 197K 39BBs 1.12 Whip

[huscroft6]

He said Hernandez "isnt there yet".

That was my point. If he isnt there, then noone is.

[upinya83]

Oh i know hus, wasn't really meant as a reply to you

just that if felix is in the conversation, greinke should be too

or that greinke never really "came back down to earth hard." either

[huscroft6]

Originally Posted by upinya83

Oh i know hus, wasn't really meant as a reply to you

just that if felix is in the conversation, greinke should be too

or that greinke never really "came back down to earth hard." either

I agree there Ups. IMO Beckett out of conversation from past 3 starts and CC doesnt stack up with the hard numbers Greinke and Felix have. Id just like to see Felix win it, im a big fan of his.

[JSi922]

i also take into fact...that your players pitch in terrible divisions and you put hernandez and greinke out there against the AL East and there numbers would get bloated.

[Yankee23]

Verlander is my AL pick

Lin and Carp is a pick em

[huscroft6]

Originally Posted by ronaldo922

i also take into fact...that your players pitch in terrible divisions and you put hernandez and greinke out there against the AL East and there numbers would get bloated.

I definetely agree there as far as saying who is a better pitcher, but with the Cy Young being a numbers award, thats why I think Felix gets it.

[DecodingMorris]

Greinke & Carpenter