Rivers or Brees?

[Pap]

If it were up to you, would you keep Rivers or bring back Brees as QB?

[rjb1816]

is it 2006 again? am i stuck in a time warp?

[Pap]

idk were the chargers 4-6 in 2006?

[be47320]

obviously a san diego bait thread

[rjb1816]

Originally Posted by The_Only_Papowski

idk were the chargers 4-6 in 2006?

they went 9-7 with brees and missed the playoffs

then 14-2 with rivers the next year

[WildKat]

Obv

[BigdaddyQH]

Only an idiot or a homer would think that Rivers is half the QB that Brees is.

[rjb1816]

Originally Posted by BigdaddyQH

Rivers is the better qb, I think

Well said

[be47320]

lol

[rjb1816]

btw solid % here lol...brees could be most overrated qb in the nfl

[be47320]

Originally Posted by rjb1816

btw solid % here lol...brees could be most overrated qb in the nfl

guy is pretty good, only qb's i would take over him are manning and brady

[rjb1816]

Originally Posted by be47320

guy is pretty good, only qb's i would take over him are manning and brady

why? what has he done in his career to make you say this? seriously, i love the guy and he brought sd back from nowhere but rivers is so far ahead of him at this point in his career compared to where brees was its not even funny. brees has always turned the ball over way too much and he hasn't changed at all...one of the reasons his qb rating is usually down

[be47320]

Originally Posted by rjb1816

why? what has he done in his career to make you say this? seriously, i love the guy and he brought sd back from nowhere but rivers is so far ahead of him at this point in his career compared to where brees was its not even funny. brees has always turned the ball over way too much and he hasn't changed at all...one of the reasons his qb rating is usually down

brees has one more int than rivers with 100 more attempts, last year brees 9 int, rivers 16.....just personal opinion..i would take brees over rivers any day of the week

[rjb1816]

obviously its an opinion, but brees is very careless with the ball...saw it all the time in sd. there are still people split down the middle on this in sd, but imo rivers will have the better career by far

[Bosox Fan]

Originally Posted by rjb1816

they went 9-7 with brees and missed the playoffs

then 14-2 with rivers the next year

In 06, Bress goes to a totally different system and goes 10-6. His team actually wins a playoff game. So you can not say that Brees was the reason that SD went 9-7 and missed the playoffs.