Vote! Which Qb you would rather have.

[larrylooser]

Just curious what others think is most important. I have chosen two random Qb's for this. Also both Qb's played the same number of years. After it's all said and done who would you take.


QB A -
Led the league 4 straight years in passing.
Threw for over 4000 yds three straight seasons.
Was just one of a handful who threw 30+ td's in back to back seasons.
Had over a 90 passing rating three straight years.
Completed over 60% of his passes for the year six times.

Post-season record 3-4 and never reached the super bowl.


QB B -
Never led the league in passing.
Never threw for 3000 yards in any season.
Threw more than 20+ td's once.
Never had a passer rating over 90.
Completed over 60% of his passes for the year twice.

Post-season record 8-2 and won two super bowl titles.


Choose which qb would you take after everything was said and done. Want to see what is important to others.

[Romanowski]

lol rivers vs ben

[larrylooser]

Originally Posted by Romanowski

lol rivers vs ben

Thank you for bringing this up. You would think so but you would be wrong nither one is rivers or ben.

[rjb1816]

it's not rivers because the first stats arent his...but i'll take the first qb all day long.

2nd one is a game manager that clearly has a superior team around him

[Sweetleaf22]

B.......easy


but your stats are way off,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,LOL



Ben has thrown for over 4,000 yards and over 3,000 yards the last 5 years.

32 TDs vs 11 Ints in 2006

Never had a passer rating over 90................ 5 times over twice under.

Completed over 60% of his passes for the year 5 times, not twice(59.9,59.7,) so just about every year.

[rjb1816]

^^^

that's because it's not him lol

[upinya83]

Originally Posted by Sweetleaf22

B.......easy


but your stats are way off,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,LOL



Ben has thrown for over 4,000 yards and over 3,000 yards the last 5 years.

32 TDs vs 11 Ints in 2006

Never had a passer rating over 90. 5 times over twice under.


Completed over 60% of his passes for the year 5 times, not twice(59.9,59.7,) so just about every year.

lol he said its not ben

since it says they "played" the same number of years, i'd guess they are retired qbs

[mrwho]

marino vs elway?

[rjb1816]

QB A might be dan fouts

[mrwho]

nevermind..just googled marino played in superbowl..

[Sweetleaf22]

Originally Posted by MrWho

nevermind..just googled marino played in superbowl..

lol,

[rjb1816]

A is fouts

[Sweetleaf22]

B is Jim Plunkett

[Steel]

QB B, Some QB's no matter how good they are they just can't win the big game. Give me the big game winner every time. After all the goal is to win the SB and its obvious that only one has accomplished that task.

[RanPicks]

gimme QB with most SB wins...

that's all I care about...