Who is a better QB: Eli Manning or Big Ben

[cuse_man]

Thought this would make a damn good poll.


Both above average-good QBs that have won superbowls...

Who do you take to lead your team... who is better ?


P.S. Bens off field issues should be out of mind for this one!

[Kacknballz]

I will take C, none of the above!

[cuse_man]

Originally Posted by Kacknballz

I will take C, none of the above!

Then you will run the wildcat... lose, and be fired.

[Kacknballz]

Originally Posted by cuse_man

Then you will run the wildcat... lose, and be fired.

Big Ben then!

[Sweetleaf22]

why not add the 3rd best qb from that class to the poll?

[cuse_man]

Originally Posted by Sweetleaf22

why not add the 3rd best qb from that class to the poll?

This is a more interesting matchup. Rivers much better than both so he would run away with it.

[PHILLYBIRDS20]

would take rivers over both but rapelisberger over ellie

[upinya83]

Originally Posted by cuse_man

This is a more interesting matchup. Rivers much better than both so he would run away with it.

agree -

ben is a runaway in this one too tho i think

[Sweetleaf22]

Ben holds rookie record – 13 consecutive wins in 13 starts.

Eli Manning was in his 3rd season when he won his 13th game.






E. Manning, Wild card round, 2005: 35.0 rating, 3 INTs, O TDs, 23-0 loss to Carolina
E. Manning, Wild card round, 2006: 85.6 rating, 2 INTs, 1 TD, 23-20 loss to Philly
E. Manning, Divisional round, 2008: 40.7 rating, 2 INTs, 0 TDs, 23-11 loss to Philly

[PHILLYBIRDS20]

thought u said stats were for losers queefy

[upinya83]

Originally Posted by Sweetleaf22

Ben holds rookie record – 13 consecutive wins in 13 starts.

Eli Manning was in his 3rd season when he won his 13th game.






E. Manning, Wild card round, 2005: 35.0 rating, 3 INTs, O TDs, 23-0 loss to Carolina
E. Manning, Wild card round, 2006: 85.6 rating, 2 INTs, 1 TD, 23-20 loss to Philly
E. Manning, Divisional round, 2008: 40.7 rating, 2 INTs, 0 TDs, 23-11 loss to Philly

i dont think there's any doubt that ben started his career better than eli - but eli has started to close the gap some over the last couple of years.

[Sweetleaf22]

Originally Posted by PHILLYBIRDS20

would take rivers over both but rapelisberger over ellie

you would take any of the 3,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,on your choke squad

[PHILLYBIRDS20]

ellie actually has gotten much better than the days of his chuck and duck. Still hate him but will give him his due

[PHILLYBIRDS20]

Originally Posted by Sweetleaf22

you would take any of the 3,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,on your choke squad

poor queefy crying cuz I didnt pick rapelisberger. Crybaby

[Sweetleaf22]

Ok this aint fantasy football.....................................im out