Who is the better QB in the NFC East?

[Dr. Jack]

McNab
Manning
Romo

Keep it on topic without getting personal

[Romanowski]

Manning IMO

[Dr. Jack]

cause he won a SB?

[Romanowski]

that and I like his style

you cant go wrong with any of them

[Dr. Jack]

True, all 3 are good.

I think McNabb has had less to work with over the years but was listening to this topic on radio and lots of good point. I can't make up my mind

[RanPicks]

any of the three are interchangeable on each team... who's better? What day is it? depends on the day...

[ZoomVT]

i think mcnabb is the better QB. manning is good and continues to improve but he makes it happen with smokes and mirrors half the time. i havenot seen a luckier QB. everytime i watch him play i wonder 2 to 3 times a game how the defender didnt catch that ball.
Romo plays solid 90% of the3 time and then he makes mistakes that really cost the team; for some reason every time he makes a mistake it translates to points for the other team.
mcNabb has had less to work with throughout his career, then add his injuries, and figure how much he has been able to do. too bad his best is past him, this is probably his last year as a top tier QB, next year manning probably takes the title of best qb in the nfc east.

[RanPicks]

It's not hard to dump the ball to Westbrook (the best Receiving RB in the game) every other play (in Reid's Offense)...

Nabb lost it for them last night... two fumbles... funny how no one is really altching on to that like they do Romo... Haters...

[pwherr]

Romo


Manning














Mcnuggets

[RanPicks]

Originally Posted by pwherr

Mcnuggets

[PHILLYBIRDS20]

Originally Posted by RanPicks

It's not hard to dump the ball to Westbrook (the best Receiving RB in the game) every other play (in Reid's Offense)...

Nabb lost it for them last night... two fumbles... funny how no one is really altching on to that like they do Romo... Haters...

McNabb has acomplished much more than Romo sure he fumbled that snap but I guess u didnt see everything else he did last night. Its not hard to be a good QB when u have arguiably the best WR in the game and maybe the best TE. McNabb much better than Romo. MANNING not in the discussion. Have u seen Mcnabbs recevers he has none and still puts up points. i seem to remember Romo losing 2 playoff games in 2 years

[RanPicks]

He's accomplished what? NFC Champ? Who cares...

McNabb plays in the great Reid offense - with arguably the most prolific RB (yds/scrimmage), one of the greatest D's (greatest D Coord..).... Can be argued either way IMO...

I don't argue that they are both great QBs... They have both choked many times (Romo handling, McNabb throwing). Eli - NYG just got on a role and capitalized on Dallas errors last year.

[TTB]

Originally Posted by PHILLYBIRDS20

McNabb has acomplished much more than Romo sure he fumbled that snap but I guess u didnt see everything else he did last night. Its not hard to be a good QB when u have arguiably the best WR in the game and maybe the best TE. McNabb much better than Romo. MANNING not in the discussion. Have u seen Mcnabbs recevers he has none and still puts up points. i seem to remember Romo losing 2 playoff games in 2 years

True Romo has a lot a weapons around him, but he is also only in his 2nd year as a starter. Everyone continues to forget this point. Can't really compare the body of work between Romo and McNabb because obviously McNabb has been a starter a lot longer. It's comical to me that everyone makes out like the Cowboys were the "team to beat" two years ago when the fumbled snap occured in Seattle. They were a 10-6 wild card team playing on the road and Romo had a whole 6 or 7 starts under his belt!! How do you guys ignore that?? He is in year 2 as a starter and off to a great start. How can everyone say that it's Brady, Peyton, and then Romo but then come in here and say he is 2nd or 3rd in his own division?? Kind of funny.

[PHILLYBIRDS20]

u never heard me say romo in that class with those guys. Dallas was the team tobeat last year. and I am prettyy sure Dallas was favored over seattle that year also

[RanPicks]

I'm not going to lie - he pissed me off last night (Romo)... But ask yourself the same question about McNabb (in his early years - or even last night)...

WTF was that damn tape on his left middle finger?!?!?! That's what caused the sh*t (fumble). Don't wear that crap, you idiot... Put a glove on or something.