Who has made more of an impact? Aaron or Brett?

[Ucanbetthat]

I have to write this since this morning I read Pete Priscos power rankings and his love affair of Aaron Rodgers and his hatred towards Brett is shown.

Aaron Rodgers Wins vs

Detroit 0-4
Minnesota 2-3

Aaron Rodgers Loses vs

Dallas 4-1
Tampa Bay 3-2
ATLANTA 3-2

Bretts Wins vs

MIAMI 2-2
Cardinals 3-2

Bretts Loses vs

Chargers 2-3
New England 3-1

[Thunder]

Haven't we heard enough of this already?

[Ucanbetthat]

Just wondering big guy, I think it's Brett obviously Aaron is playing with the same team Brett had last year and Brett was 13-3.

[Dr. Jack]

I am one of the rare ones that do not understand why people pick or hate on Brett Favre. The guy is a winner, plain and simple. He has won a title, MVP, owns a lot of records and has been as durable as anyone.

I don’t think the Packers are losing because of Rodgers though. He is playing better than most people outside of GB thought he would (I am guessing). They probably were not as good as their 13-3 record last year.

Bottom line – Rodgers might have a bright future but he is certainly no Brett Favre

[Ucanbetthat]

Well put. Aaron Rodger has great potential! He has shown signs of a grood leader and pretty smart decision maker. Brett is Brett. I still think with Brett this year they are 4-1 minimum right now.