Am I being unreasonable with this trade offer?

[Bobtheicon]

I think it's fair. My team is stacked with receivers:
Calvin Johnson
Steve Smith
Hakeem Nicks
Johnny Knox
Malcolm Floyd
Sidney Rice (okay,.. whatever).,

Other guy NEEDS some WR points. He's got:
Desean Jackson
Bernard Berrian
Donald Driver
Derrick Mason
Lee Evans

I want his QB (Tom Brady), he's got Rothlesburger on the bench. I offered Hakeem Nicks and Chad Henne for Brady. In the notes I said he could have ANY of my receivers plus either Henne or Cutler for Brady. I didn't offer Cutler originally cause he made fun of me for taking him in the draft.

Is this unreasonable? Seems to me that you can get points out of a lot of QBs, but you gotta get some WR points and that's what I'm offering. Maybe I'm just being a dick.

[Bobtheicon]

Oh, and I won my first game scoring 100 pts, he lost his first game scoring 43 pts.

[walk066]

I hope you get that deal Bob. I don't think it's unreasonable.

[be47320]

not unreasonable and a great deal for you with your wr core

nicks will be the #1 in ny this year

[Bobtheicon]

Thanks. Yeah, that's what I'm selling Nicks on too. I think it's a win/win.

[be47320]

think nicks will put up better numbers than johnson even though calvin is a freak....just due to their situations...you might even try a straight up johson for brady deal...people couldnt bitch about that

[Bobtheicon]

Good idea. Well, I did already offer (not formally) any of my receivers PLUS either of my QBs (Cutler or Henne) for Brady. Maybe I'm being too generous there? I know he thinks I'm trying to f*ck him, but I'm not.

[Cali Roots]

It is not a fair trade at all. IMO Nicks needs to show more than 1 good week. Brady is proven and Nicks is not. I would never do the deal if I was the other guy. If Nicks is a stud a few weeks into the season than you may have an argument. It is too early for Nicks.