I have to do this right?

[westcoastO]

vick's for real. QBs get some crazy ass points in my league and carson palmer just isnt cuttin it, and mike vick is torching the entire nfl

i give: frank gore, josh freeman

i get: michael bush (handcuff mcfadden) mike vick

yeah?

[Bisket]

wouldn't do it just because of andy reid

if they were to lose next week, I wouldn't be shocked if Kolb is back out there

[westcoastO]

the way he's played i just don't see how he could ever bench him.

[be47320]

man crush

[ConstantColorUpor]

Who are your other rbs? If you have some depth aside from Mcfadden I think its a must. 6 pt passing tds or 4?

[westcoastO]

6 pt passing TDs, could be more too depending how long they are.

other RBs are jamaal charles, jonathan stewart and benjarvus green ellis

[Stubudd]

whoa, frank gore for vick? man....

i don't know...

Vick beat up the lay downs and Jax (who are apparently pretty terrible), yea he looks amazing, but...

this could end up looking like an insane week 3 panic trade possibly...

who knows though

[Stubudd]

Originally Posted by westcoastO

6 pt passing TDs, could be more too depending how long they are.

other RBs are jamaal charles, jonathan stewart and benjarvus green ellis

So you gonna end up with the raiders starter and one of 3 back ups? Did charles get the ball today?

trade gore to go from carson to vick? i don't know man

what QBs are on waivers?

[ConstantColorUpor]

Leaves you a little weak at RB, but the guys you have showed a lot of promise this week. Mcfadden continuing to produce, Green Ellis looks to be the new starter in NE, Charles although still not being the starter in KC, still producing like a RB2 and his touches will only increase, Stewart scored today, and the move gets you a handcuff and a guy that was hyped coming into this year anyways as someone who was going to be a steal in this years FF drafts. Think if I was in your spot I would try to negociate and try to give up Charles or Mcfadden instead of Gore, but if that does work I think I would still do it.

IMO if you want to win going forward you cant stick with Palmer at QB, I think this move is obvious even though your giving up a RB1. Id rather start 2 RB2's and have a legit top 7 fantasy qb in Vick (who might as well be an additional RB2 in your starting lineup with the rush yards and tds youll get), than a RB1, RB2 and a top 20 fantasy QB. Id make the move, especially with how your scoring works. Vick will get a lot of long tds to those young WRs this year. To me EVERYTHING points to yes in this deal, the key though is your league settings based on what you have said, I assume QBs, especially those with big play ability, are very valuable.

[Stubudd]

Originally Posted by westcoastO

vick's for real. QBs get some crazy ass points in my league and carson palmer just isnt cuttin it, and mike vick is torching the entire nfl

i give: frank gore, josh freeman

i get: michael bush (handcuff mcfadden) mike vick

yeah?

mike vick fever

[BLBisinnocent]

take a look at vick's schedule the rest of the season....no more Jacksonville's.....no more Detroit's......

I can't stress enough for you to not do this trade.....Vick is at the highest of his sell-high value right now.....you really want to trade for him, do it in 2 weeks when you can give up mcfadden for him instead of gore.....

[westcoastO]

yikes. offered the trade but have until tuesday before he can accept, so i can withdraw it. reading some of your comments i'm starting to think i might have to.

i know he torched detroit and jacksonville, but he did it to the packers too, their defense isn't nearly on the level of shit as the other 2

i'm going to probably withdraw this and stick it out with what i have.

the other thing, the guy i'm looking to trade with has scored the most points each week the first 3 weeks, and giving him gore for vick (who is on his bench) only bolsters his lineup.

tough situation, i need a better QB to compete, but giving him gore probably wins the league for him.

appreciate the input fellas, more opinions welcome too

[be47320]

vick will be hut by week 8 anyway...ill bump this

[chibob]

Is Sanchez available? When Holmes is good to go, the kid has a lot of good weapons, better than Cincy's

[westcoastO]

sanchez actually isn't available. i just withdrew the trade.

guy is a real cocksucker. he has vick sitting on his bench but says he wont trade him for anyone other than an elite rb.

offered him a couple 2 for 1 trades, charles and mike wallace, mcfadden and dez bryant, etc. he's saying no.

this guy serious? giving him 2 players who he'd start for a ****ing guy on his bench. fantasy football gay