input on final trade offer

[westcoastO]

it's the same shit as before, still trying to trade for vick. guy has finally come to his senses and brought vick's asking price down

i give:
dez bryant, darren mcfadden, chad henne, chiefs d

i get:
mike vick, mike bell, braylon edwards, 49ers d

my starting QB is palmer, he sucks, i need a new one

i have jamaal charles and frank gore at RB so i can afford mcfadden, thoughts?

[upinya83]

i like this deal alot better than your other ones

who is his starting qb gonna be?

[bigsportsguy2006]

i like this deal a lot too ...

ups, he already had someone else as his starter (i think it was peyton manning), vick was just his backup

[westcoastO]

yeah, his starting qb is peyton manning. guy has the most points in the league and he's 3-0 so i didn't wanna give up too much

what's the deal with braylon, he's not gonna get suspended is he?

[upinya83]

Originally Posted by westcoastO

yeah, his starting qb is peyton manning. guy has the most points in the league and he's 3-0 so i didn't wanna give up too much

what's the deal with braylon, he's not gonna get suspended is he?

Yeah, I'm always afraid of turning another team into a superteam - if everyone else in your league would make him keep both peyton and vick, then he'd be screwed. But someone is gonna trade for him anyway, so may as well be you. He's probably gonna be tough to beat though.

[westcoastO]

i haven't read anything about braylon yet, anyone know what his deal is? will he get suspended by the league at all?

if braylon is a go, with sanchez looking like an actual NFL qb, i think this is a done deal after this week ends

[chibob]

Originally Posted by westcoastO

i haven't read anything about braylon yet, anyone know what his deal is? will he get suspended by the league at all?

if braylon is a go, with sanchez looking like an actual NFL qb, i think this is a done deal after this week ends

I doubt he gets suspended, but I hope he does, the same week Holmes comes off his supension. Homes, from the lips of Rex, is the best player on the team

[HotStreak]

I think you are getting a little bit the worst of it. He seems to get 3 upgrades and you get Vick. The guy almost HAS to trade Vick. He is NEVER going to start him over Manning. I think McFadden for Vick straight up is a very fair deal at this point in the season. Throw in Henne to give the guy a back up for Mannings bye week, and ask for Braylon Edwards to even it out. Edwards is a WR 3 at best with Holmes back next week.


In the end, if this guy keeps being a dick, pick up Bradford if he's still there , and play match up roulette with your three QB's. McFadden is looking like he will be a valuable asset. People are going to be desperate at RB as the injuries pile up. You'll get your Vick or a better QB soon if McFadden continues his top RB performance and you are willing to move him.

In the end, if he doesn't budge, I guess

[westcoastO]

really appreciate the input

i should note that my league gives 6 points for passing TDs instead of 4. all TDs in my league are 6 points.

but for TDs 10-39 yards, it's 9 points, TDs 40-60 yards, 12 points, TDs over 60 yards are 14 points. so you can see how valuable it is to have a good QB and playmakers that go for long TDs

knowing that, would you still say i get ripped?

remember, carson palmer is my QB, no good. and the other thing is, the guy will eventually get a deal for vick, so if i dont act soon i lose out.