lopsided trade but it might make sense for my team?

[be47320]

guy offers me witten and chargers d

for deshawn jackson and jamal lewis


already have ap, jones drew and chris johnson and have santonio holmes and brandon marshal at wr with some decent bench guys like dwayne bowe.

im starting scheffler at te right now

sounds lopsided but if i took it my lineup would be pretty stout

brees
ap
chris jonhson/jones drew
santonio
marshall
witten
chargers d

any thoughts?

[jonny delta]

current D?

[be47320]

san fran

[Keith]

I would NOT do that deal. And yes I know it improves your team, but I think you are not getting enough value for what you are giving up.

[PGAman]

You also have to think does this make his team a lot better?
I was in the same situation and decided against a trade because my team is already very good.

I have Scheffler at TE in one of my leagues as well.
Chargers D will not be anything special after Merriman gone.

Is Buffalo available?

I think you are basically giving up Jackson and Lewis for Witten.
I would steer away because you already have a good team.

AP, MJD, Lewis, and Johnson are 4 good backs.

You start 3 rb and 2 wr in your league?

[jonny delta]

Ah San Fran..w/Mississippi's own P Willie at LB...unfortuanely he doesn't have a great deal of help....

Granted Merriman's out now, but SD is a very nice upgrade over SF...

Always tough to give up a decent RB2 imo, and I think DeJack will have a good year...but I'd probably make the deal as a good D can carry you a long way...Witten no slouch either - GL

[be47320]

thanks for the feedback guys, going to sleep on it

[sigep792002]

You can always look at matchups and pick up a D off the waiver wire. There is always at least 1 Defense on the waiver wire that is going up against an inept offense. Pick a new D week to week

[RanPicks]

Also - dont forget about if it helps him more than you...

[spliff]

counteroffer Lewis for Witten