McCluster & Randy Moss for Torain & Santana Moss?

[L'il G]

Which end of this deal would you want?

I picked up Torain on waivers a few weeks ago. I think he'll do well until Portis gets back and might be ok afterwards. I already have Ryan Mathews, Arian Foster, and Ronnie Brown at RB and OchoCinco, Dez Bryant and Johnny Knox at WR (2 RB, 2WR, 1 flex league).

My real concern is Favre quitting mid-season. I'd hate to have Tavaris Jackson throwing to my WR1. If Favre stays, I believe Moss could put up some big numbers when Sidney Rice gets back.

Mayyyyyyyybe McCluster ends up exploding at the end of the season, but he's likely a non-factor in this trade.

[Keith]

I would want Torrain and Santana Moss. McCluster is too unreliable, and any return TDs he has go to the Chiefs D and not him. Moss is an aging prima donna, who will do well, but probably will not outproduce Santana Moss for the season. Torrain is the # 1 guy in Washington (for the moment). I've read that Portis will not be back.