need to hold on to one of these

[capperdan]

in general:
who has more upside shockey or deangelo williaims ???

[Keith]

tough call there. Is it a PPR league ? If yes, then probably Shockey. But of course if you could draft Jonathan Stewart, then you'd want Williams to handcuff him with.

[be47320]

shockey, deangelo williams will never be a feature back and get 20 + carries per game

[Keith]

Originally Posted by be47320

shockey, deangelo williams will never be a feature back and get 20 + carries per game

But if you are not getting points for receptions, then Shockey's value is ALOT less.

[capperdan]

1 pt for all receptions
which would be great for williams too...
just depends on his playing time.
Always have been high on him and thought
he would shine w/ release of foster then
came stewart!

[capperdan]

Originally Posted by Keith

tough call there. Is it a PPR league ? If yes, then probably Shockey. But of course if you could draft Jonathan Stewart, then you'd want Williams to handcuff him with.

Carolina seems to always have a rb by commitee.
Could hurt to have both

[Keith]

Originally Posted by capperdan

Carolina seems to always have a rb by commitee.
Could hurt to have both

I am a fan of securing both RBs (in an RBBC situation) for at least one team. Shockey is still injury-prone and is coming off a broken leg. I'd keep Williams and try to draft Stewart.

[da_boy]

I'd keep shockey especially if you have to start at least 1 TE. he'll probably end up top 5 TE and the way the saints run their offense, he should get a lot of touches.

As far as Williams, I always thought he was the better back but they never game him the chance to be their number one. I drafted him the last 2 years waiting for his breakout that never happened. There must be something wrong with him for the panthers to keep passing him over.