need running back help as usual i cant decide

[teddystally]

[Islaton vs. buff 32 nd run def
chris johnson vs. jax 12 th run def
pierre thomas vs. atlanta 23 rd run def ( on monday night )

please pick two of these three

any help would be much appreciated


thanks fellas[/I]

[Hammer&Sickle]

Call me crazy, but I believe that Thomas blows up on Monday night.

[dhunter]

can't bench cj

cj and slaton

[teddystally]

ty hammer and dhunter. i tend to agree with you hammer (this is what im strugglin with)
i usually start monday nite players, but cj is very solid, but atlantas run d sucks.


another question i have schaub and garrard. schaub plays in a dome and he will be in buffalo this weekend. garrard lit up tennesse last time, think he will do it again this weekend.

[dhunter]

this one is not even close. schaub by a mile

[teddystally]

thanks dhunter

[teddystally]

even though garrard is playin the worst pass defense in the league?

[walk066]

Slaton and CJ.

You can never bench your starter because you think your backup has a better matchup.

[chibob]

Originally Posted by teddystally

thanks dhunter

Not so fast

Is A Johnson's lung going to stop bleeding long enough for him to be effective?

If he is out it may have a significant effect on Schaubs production and Buf may pull the upset.

[chibob]

Originally Posted by dhunter

this one is not even close. schaub by a mile

Could be, no, it is serious bad advice, as it isn't a mile lead by Schaube, my starter. Slaton gets a ton of action against a poor rush D, and if AJ is limited????



David Garrard - JAX - Four times in his career David Garrard has passed or thrown for 3 TDs in a game. Two of those games have come against the Titans, and one of them was four weeks ago when he completed 27-of37 attempts for 323 yards at home against Tennessee. Garrard has been shaky on the road this year, but the Titans are easily the best possible matchup for quarterbacks allowing an average of 326 yards, 3.2 TDs and 0.7 INTs per game. Opposing QBs are completing a ridiculous 74% of their passes against them, which is understandable since they've registered only 11 sacks and 4 interceptions, and their opponent's passer rating is 117.5. Mark Sanchez was the only QB not to throw for over 300 yards against the Titans, though he did score 3 TDs. The only QB not to score at least 3 TDs was Ben Roethlisberger in Week 1, but he wasn't disappointing with 363 yds. Needless to say, barring a missed bed check by Mike Sims-Walker, Garrard looks like a great quarterback to have if you paired him with Roethlisberger, Tom Brady or Carson Palmer, who are all on their bye this week

Good luck, however you decide.

[upinya83]

A Johnson practiced today 100% of reps

[dhunter]

Originally Posted by chibob

Four times in his career David Garrard has passed or thrown for 3 TDs in a game.

schaub has 3+ in 3 games this year.

on the surface the bills pass defense looks much better but if you take a closer look you'll see that they faced the carolina, jets, browns, dolphins. all weak passing teams. leftwich threw for 296 and 3TDs lol.

gl with garrard tho

[chibob]

Originally Posted by dhunter

schaub has 3+ in 3 games this year.

on the surface the bills pass defense looks much better but if you take a closer look you'll see that they faced the carolina, jets, browns, dolphins. all weak passing teams. leftwich threw for 296 and 3TDs lol.

gl with garrard tho

You always miss the point

[spliff]

i's stick with Schaub. You never know what you're going to get with Gerard.

as for the rb's, I do like PT, but he is sharing the ball with 2 other guys and loses many of the gl carries. I'd start Slaton and CJ.

[teddystally]

thanks fellas you all make interesting and very valid points. i am leaning schaub but theres a 70% chance of rain and winds in the 30mph range. although garrard will also be playin in the rain but with no wind factor. again ty for your input