Need some advice on a trade...

[makebank1024]

Ok....got screwed and missed my draft and I think ESPN's autopicker was on some bad drugs...

on that note... I am in desperate need of a QB since the only one on my team right now is Brodie Croyle (KC). I am have decent RBs and am much weaker at WR though. Here is a proposed trade...

Send Earnest Graham, TB RB
Send Brandon Marshall*, Den WR
Receive David Garrard, Jac QB
Receive Willie Parker, Pit RB

I believe Garrard is an average QB in a run-heavy offense. However, I am not going to survive with just Brodie throwing for me. Parker is a strong RB in my opinion so I actually think I gain some in that department aside from what the so called "experts" say or what draft position he goes.

Any advice would be appreciated if this trade is beneficial...

Side note... Other notable players I have
Frank Gore (RB - SF)
Maurice Jones-Drew (RB, JAX)
Kevin Smith (RB- DET)
Torry Holt (WR-STL)
Steve Smith (WR - NYG)
Vincent Jackson (WR-SD)
James Hardy (WR-BUF)

[makebank1024]

any suggestions i would really appreciate cause i only have a 24 hr window...thanks mall

[Jahred]

dont do it.

gerrard is not worth marshal and a rb like grahm imo.

who is a free agent out there to replace croyle?

[makebank1024]

its a 16 team league so the FA pool is slim...although someone dropped trent edwards so i am getting him off waivers and getting rid of croyle...other than that there are no 1st stringers...i was considering brady quinn just to have if anderson's injury is more serious but i dont think it is

[Jahred]

croyle could be a sleeper this year makebank,

teams will be testing him especially with larry johnson behind him. Theyll take away the run most of the time imo. Theyve always had a goto guy in Tony Gonzales now they have Bowe as a quality 2nd option in the air.

Id keep him and see what happens through the first few weeks. I think Marshal is what the other guy is going for anyways, he is worth keeping.

[makebank1024]

yeah...that def could be true...if croyle's preseason performance wasn't so lackluster i wouldn't be so worried...but i really don't want to part with marshall...cutler is just getting better with every year imo and with his 3 game suspension down to just the 1 game he should put up a solid fantasy season...graham just worried me a bit too with the likes of dunn, bennett, williams also present but with cadillac getting hurt its a bit better

[makebank1024]

oh one more question....i have shawn alexander on teh bench...you think he will ever land on his feet on a team?? or is he wasted space?

[Keith]

I wouldn't do that trade, but you MUST get rid of Croyle. I may be in the minority, but I think Garrard will be a top 10 (top 12 for sure) QB this year.

[makebank1024]

yeah i do like garrard and parker...just don't know if i am giving up too much to get them

[makebank1024]

bump.....would still love some more advice guys...any comment would help