Are these trades lopsided?

[L'il G]

This league doesn't put trades to a majority vote -- the commissioner is the only one with veto power, and he's throwing a fit over these trades.

Matt Cassel and Brandon Jacobs for Philip Rivers

Ahmad Bradshaw and Randy Moss for Steven Jackson

Are these trades worthy of a veto?

[mood77]

Thanks for the response on my thread....I don't think either of these trades are lopsided...both seem fair in my opinion

[Bobtheicon]

You can trade this late?
They look fine to me, but maybe he's throwing a fit cause it helps a playoff bound team? I thought most leagues stop trades at Thanksgiving.

[L'il G]

It's a weird league. I tried to put those trades through with another team that I am in playoff contention with, and the commissioner vetoed it because I'm playing him this week.

Anyway, I caught him cheating last night and printed out proof, so I'm hoping he DQ's his (first-place) team and an extra team is allowed into the playoffs.

[mikeswinner]

the bradshaw trade is fine, but the cassel trade is ridiculous, rivers is far more valuable that those hacks