Thoughts on this trade offer??

[TTB]

I have been offered Addai, Winslow, and Calvin Johnson for AP, S. Holmes, and Carlson. The guy offering me the deal is sprung on AP and is willing to give me this much for him. I would get a shot in the arm at TE and WR with Winslow and Calvin and Addai IMO might not be far off from AP. I honestly don't think AP will ever make it through a complete NFL season and I was never all that excited to draft him because I knew the injury bug would always be there. Obviously I am liking the deal but just wondered what you guys thought.

[cuse_man]

seems like you are big on addai, but you think its good for me to give him up for perry ??? Im thinking about asking for slaton/perry for addai....?

[Uncle C]

I would do it. You might lose that 1 or 2 huge games AP will have but overall I think you ugrade your lineup. I have AP and have the same concerns about him you do.

[TTB]

Originally Posted by cuse_man

seems like you are big on addai, but you think its good for me to give him up for perry ??? Im thinking about asking for slaton/perry for addai....?

I can't lie to you Cuse. I really like the deal you are involved in because you would get Tony. I have Slaton in two of the four leagues I am in and I am very high on him. If he looked that good in his first start against as good a defense as Tennessee he has a shot to be pretty good.

[cuse_man]

Originally Posted by That Texas Boy!

I can't lie to you Cuse. I really like the deal you are involved in because you would get Tony. I have Slaton in two of the four leagues I am in and I am very high on him. If he looked that good in his first start against as good a defense as Tennessee he has a shot to be pretty good.

im getting slaton and perry +moss and romo now

[TTB]

Originally Posted by cuse_man

im getting slaton and perry +moss and romo now

[cuse_man]

still a bit shakey about it... kinda think he got ther better end of the deal but hey