Trade Help: Gates and Rodgers for Chris Johnson and Boldin??????

[ZoomVT]

Would you do it?

On one hand i feel is too high for a TE, on the other hand Boldin might be a bit overvalued right now.

I also dont have a reliable QB, McNabb and Favre.

I have a stable of RBs but im weak at WR so i'd hate giving up a WR. My only other WR is Garcon.
thoughts?

[upinya83]

i would take the cj & boldin side of this deal

not sure which side is yours

[ZoomVT]

the wrong one. LOL

i could really use rodgers, gates i dont know how much of an upgrade over witten the way SD is playing.

[HotStreak]

Keep Johnson and Boldin

[Trossi3389]

Rogers,Gates & Johnson are SOLID... boldin will stay streaky.

Do the math.

[ZoomVT]

thanks for the replies.

i guess i should just stay pat.

[upinya83]

Originally Posted by ZoomVT

thanks for the replies.

i guess i should just stay pat.

i would - does this guy have a decent backup qb and backup te, where his dropoffs wont be as drastic, and he's adding the best player in the league

there's a reason teams dont trade within their own division

sometimes its not worth making your team a bit stronger, when in return you're helping build a miami heat, if that makes sense

[pigskin punk]

Boldin will probably get hurt again playing in that division.

[ZoomVT]

Yeah, his backup is Eli and Gresham for TE.

I am not doing this trade, I would be handing him the trophy.

If i could get rodgers and gates, for 2 RB (not C. Johnson), or boldin and a different RB i would consider it.

[rjb1816]

did you really say you dont know how much of an upgrade gates is over witten? really? i didnt even know people still owned witten in leagues

[ZoomVT]

LOL

its like a magnet... you must use some advanced searching.

gates is an upgrade over witten, no questions about that. Is it a significant # of points every week to justify moving a #1 and #2? I am not sure about that. I find it difficult to think that just the TE would break me every week.

But this is why im asking.

[rjb1816]

if your starting te is witten then yes it is a significant upgrade. Over the first 3 weeks he's outperformed him by dd's every week. So that is a difference of likely a few wins over the course of a season

[chibob]

Originally Posted by ZoomVT

the wrong one. LOL

i could really use rodgers, gates i dont know how much of an upgrade over witten the way SD is playing.

Has Harris of the Bears embedded in his pillow and is having troubles sleeping at night

[Stubudd]

Originally Posted by rjb1816

if your starting te is witten then yes it is a significant upgrade. Over the first 3 weeks he's outperformed him by dd's every week. So that is a difference of likely a few wins over the course of a season

Yea, maybe the guy will trade him gates straight up for witten...


but until he does, you have to consider the context of the trade