trade offer...thoughts?

[Amish Porn Star]

This is a 14-tm PPR league. start 1-2-3-1-1-1 plus a flex. Here is the offer:

Arian Foster and Brandon Gibson

for

Benjarvus Green-Ellis, Denarius Moore and Daniel Thomas.

Below is my roster; keep in mind how thin a 14-team, 18-man roster league can be.

Bradford, Sam STL QB 31.45 5
Vick, Michael PHI QB (Q) 48.65 7

Addai, Joseph IND RB 21.30 11
Forsett, Justin SEA RB 10.10 6
Graham, Earnest TBB RB 24.00 8
Green-Ellis, BenJarvus NEP RB 23.90 7
Hillis, Peyton CLE RB (Q) 42.40 5
Redman, Isaac PIT RB 13.70 11
Thomas, Daniel MIA RB (R) 12.70 5

Holmes, Santonio NYJ WR (Q) 26.20 8
Johnson, Calvin DET WR (Q) 44.70 9
Moore, Denarius OAK WR (R) 28.10 8
Roberts, Andre ARI WR 10.10 6
Welker, Wes NEP WR 51.10 7

Gonzalez, Tony ATL TE 39.50 8
Kendricks, Lance STL TE (R) 6.40 5

Brown, Josh STL PK 18.90 5
Lions, Detroit DET Def 25.00 9

[Hoosiercatdaddy]

I would say you have to do that but I dont see who you are going to start until Foster comes back. That's a high risk, very high reward trade for you. If Foster comes back within a few weeks, this trade is a no brainer. But after Hillis, you have no one to start until then and he might be out longer than we think. I think you are safe to stay put right now with your WRs being so solid

[Wabash Wonders]

Personally, I would never do this trade. But I really like Thomas and think he will eventually be the clear #1 back in Miami and have a very nice year. Foster will never be "The Man" again in Houston with Ben Tate around. With Foster's type of injury(hamstring, he is still questionable for this week and probably wont play)), he more than likely will never be 100% this year or even close to it even if he does come back and gets the starting role. I rate Moore much higher than Gibson also, so you would be giving up way too much in my opinion...

[Amish Porn Star]

thx guys for the replies. I was leaning toward my lineup status quo, as I am 2nd leading scorer now. I hope you are right about Thomas, WW. You guys confirmed my hunch, STAY PUT and pray Hillis and Vick stay healthy. My WRs are rocking.

[spliff]

DT may even outscore Foster this year. It won't be difficult at the current pace.