Traded Roddy White for Pierre Thomas...did I upgrade or downgrade my team?

[allstr921]

Starters - 12 team lg

Farve/Ryan/Orton - who would you start
Colston
Driver
Nate Washington replaces White
Arian Foster
MJD
Heap
Pierre Thomas

i picked up nate washington, I did have ricky williams start last week in the flex spot

bench
Lee Evans
Bernard Berrian
mcgahee
rickey williams


Would you start Berrian over Washington? maybe Berian this week cuz washington has Pitt D?

Thanks for your input guys, 1-0 in this lg and think I have a really good team just iffy on the washington/berrian pick....lee evans is only for an emergency bye week filler

[danv6]

Dont like the trade...leaves you weak at wr in my opinion plus you had MJD and Foster...Id start Orton against Seahawks

[ConstantColorUpor]

bad trade you were set at rb, now with the trade you will be struggling week to week for wr help

[Hoosiercatdaddy]

didnt need a RB, especially a loser like Pierre. You gave up a top 5 WR for a position that you didnt need

Arian Foster and MJD are studs that will carry you. I see you a FLEX position which Thomas would fit in but u think with Bush in there too, Roddy would have gave you better numbers

[allstr921]

thanks guys....i'm a moron, lol

[Wabash Wonders]

Lesson learned I hope...Next time use this Forum for its meant for and ask the question before making the trade.

[HotStreak]

I agree.

You needed White more than Thomas.

[Burgh Brew Crew]

Well on the bright side you are solid at rb see if you can flip say williams for high number 2 maybe low number 1 wr depending on who is weak at the rb position.

[mogies]

i agree with everyone else, bad trade, maybe you can look to move someone else and get that dept you need, you might be 1-0 now, but one or two injuries and you will be at the bottom looking up...

[pigskin punk]

Boo, Boo. Not good for you.

[westcoastO]

you running backs were awesome already. the league should have veto'd this one IMO, sorry just bein honest.

[westcoastO]

just further adding what i dont get here, i mean you got a guy in thomas who will lose time to reggie bush for a guy in roddy white who is the ONLY target in ATL other than gonzalez. who the hell is the #2 WR in atl? jenkins??? doubt these guys are owned in any leagues as it is. see if you can pay him off and get white back bro

[ConstantColorUpor]

Your best chance is if Ricky and Berrian have some good performances soon and you can package them to get a WR2, doubt you can get a top 5-7 fantasy WR like White but you can get some value. Or maybe Berrian will emerge in that offense and you wont need to do anything, slim chance, but Favre needs to throw to someone.